Perspectives

What's an Ornate Website Worth in the Age of AI?

By Robert Johns

Over the last few weeks, I've come across some truly beautiful websites. They had big animation and rich illustration, the kind of craft that makes you stop scrolling, and I enjoyed every one of them. But once I closed the tab, I realized I couldn't say what most of those companies actually do, or what they believe.

That got me thinking: what's the value of an ornate website, especially in the age of AI?

To answer that, it helps to look at how a website's job has changed over the last 30 years. At first, just having a website signaled that a company was ahead of the curve. Then sites had to be useful: a place to learn about the product, find the right person or buy something. Eventually, a polished, impressive site became a signal of its own. It told investors and customers that a company was serious, well funded and capable of building something real.

Today, polish is losing its signaling power for two key reasons. The first is that it got cheap. A small team can now produce a site that would have taken an agency months a few years ago, so an ornate site says much less about the team behind it.

The second is that fewer people are visiting websites altogether. When Google shows an AI summary, people click through to a site about half as often, and half of B2B software buyers now start their research in a chatbot instead of a search engine. By the time someone lands on a company's site, they've often already asked an AI about it and are there to confirm what they heard. None of the design shaped that first impression, because the AI only read what the site says.

Put those together, and an overdesigned site can start to work against a company. Visitors arrive with a question, and the design that once signaled ambition now stands between them and the answer.

That doesn't mean design stops mattering, or that any site will do as long as the words are right. A dated or neglected site sends a signal too: when a site looks like no one has touched it in years, it's fair to wonder what else is being neglected. As I like to say, "How you do anything is how you do everything." The goal is somewhere in between: clean, current, distinct and clear about what the company does, with visuals that serve that message instead of competing with it.

Mature companies like Anduril, Palantir and SpaceX get this right. Their sites are simple, sharp and clearly maintained, built to get visitors quickly to what they came for. The impact comes from years of real media: launch footage, product in the field, the actual hardware. The visuals are impressive because the work is, and they always point back at what the company builds.

Early-stage companies, however, rarely have these kinds of media assets yet, and it's tempting to let design fill the gap. It's a reasonable instinct when there isn't much to show. But it's worth asking whether an ornate site is helping people understand the company or just making it seem impressive. I even asked a few VC friends about this. Most said they barely look at a site before there's a product, and what bothered them wasn't polish but design that got in the way. One told me that when a startup makes him sit through an intricate animation just to scroll, he starts to wonder what they're compensating for.

A site doesn't need to be plain. But the design is no longer the signal; clarity is. An ornate site can still leave people impressed while failing to tell them what the company builds. In that case, it did a job, just not the one it was hired to do.

Originally published on X. Follow Robert Johns.

Work With Us

Whether it’s a logo, a website, a film or the whole brand, we’re here to help.

Contact

A person working at a desk, seen through reeded glass